Bench insights
How has this judge decided questions like yours?
For matters in the UK Supreme Court, Court of Appeal, High Court, Family Court, EAT and Upper Tribunal: choose
the judge — or let Litora read the “Before:” from your latest order or judgment. Ask your question
in plain English, pick the last one to five years, and Litora reads that judge’s published judgments on Find
Case Law (The National Archives): the facts, what was decided and why. The percentage is counted from those
judgments, never guessed — it is not a prediction.
- Every judgment shown is real and links to the official judgment
- What has persuaded this bench, and what has not
- Download as a PDF or email it to yourself
Your question · last 3 years
Does this judge allow appeals where interview evidence should have been excluded under PACE s.78?
In 6 of 8 published judgments that bear on it, the answer was yes. High confidence
J1Appeal allowed — s.58 breach, interview should have been excludedCourt of Appeal (Criminal Division) · 2025
J2Appeal dismissed — breach not significant and substantialCourt of Appeal (Criminal Division) · 2024